Cars I Own

  • Profile picture of %s
     
    I'm looking for a hatchback. Have narrowed down my search to the following cars: 1. Swift 2. Punto 3. Polo 4. i20 My monthly travel will likely be around 1000-1500/month. I need the car within one month. Please suggest if I should buy the diesel variant or the petrol? Which car should I buy? (I guess I have already ruled out swift :P)
    29 answers
      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Shreyans Jain 1 year, 3 months ago

        Within one month means you can pretty much forget every diesel except the Punto. However, your running does not necessarily warrant a diesel. Among the petrols I’d say choose between the Swift and the Polo. The 1.6 Polo is one fun car. I will not recommend the i20 now as an updated model is due.

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Aravindhan 1 year, 3 months ago

        You should definitely go for a diesel variant since your monthly running is high (excess of 1000 km). Among the choices you have mentioned, the Punto will be available mostly within a month. Punto is a great looking premium hatchback, has solid build quality and packs in most of the features offered by its rivals. But Fiat’s after sales service is…[Read more]

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Shreyans Jain 1 year, 3 months ago

        I beg to differ with Aravindhan a bit. I feel with 1-1.5k monthly running, a diesel is not an absolute must. Lets not forget that apart from a direct 1-1.25 lakh price difference, most of these hatches have additional discounts and schemes on their petrol variants, which are not available otherwise. So we are effectively looking at a difference…[Read more]

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Somasundaram Krishnan Kutty 1 year, 3 months ago

        Farhan, go for Polo Petrol (1.6)! Dependable hatch, design will look fresh even after 10 years. It’s an investment, you don’t have to look for another car for 10 years!

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Shreyans Jain 1 year, 3 months ago

        Punto 1.3 Dynamic is a very competent car in itself.

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Rishabh P Nair 1 year, 3 months ago

        You should opt for the Fiat Punto it’s available off the shelf and is a very satisfying vehicle. The Service too promises to improve in the near future. The i20 is also a nice option but the new i20 is expected to come out and if I had time on my hand I would wait for it.

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Babychen Mathew 1 year, 3 months ago

        At max 1500 km, you can go with either one. If you are buying on EMI mostly though, diesel might save you more money. Swift is out as you need it in one month. I will rank your choices as i20, Polo and Punto. i20, because the new i20 is cming, and the current one may not be in high demand. with luck, some good discount is also possible. Polo for…[Read more]

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Farhan Kash 1 year, 3 months ago

        i would have opted for i20 , first its facelift is coming upfront and the current model is still having waiting of 60days

      • Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
         
        Rishabh P Nair 1 year, 3 months ago

        Go for the Punto. Its available off the shelf and is a good package overall.

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Farhan Kash 1 year, 3 months ago

        i have decided that i will go with punto 1.3 dynamic. gonna book the car tomorrow hopefully

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Somasundaram Krishnan Kutty 1 year, 3 months ago

        Good luck Farhan! Be a good defensive driver, do not forget to use seat belt! Punto is a nice car only worry is servicing!

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Babychen Mathew 1 year, 3 months ago

        Have you booked it? let us know how your dealer experience was!

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Nohan John 1 year, 3 months ago

        if u have budget of 7+ then go i20 diesel!!! facelift version(new)

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Ashish Rana 1 year, 2 months ago

        u take new swift VDI which has got a new engine and a pikup in 2 gear swift runs at speed of 80 km/h

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Mayank Mittal 1 year, 2 months ago

        Frahan do upload a dealer review, as the servicing n hospitality of fiat is always a topic of discussion

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Mayank Mittal 1 year, 2 months ago

        after your first servicing do let the community know if you found it to your expectation

    Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
  • Profile picture of %s
     
    Really in a fix,need to decide which suv to buy out of the Mahindra XUV500 or Tata Safari Storme?. What I like about the XUV500 is that it is feature packed but I dont like its MUV kind of looks. On the other hand safari looks far more rugged and suv like but sadly its not feature packed. So which is better out of the two?
    5 answers
      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Roshun Povaiah 1 year, 3 months ago

        It’s a tough choice. The Safari Storme is definitely an improved version of the existing Safari (although the look is slightly toned down). But when you compare it to the XUV, the XUV offers far more features. In terms of performance too, the XUV is slightly better than the Storme (because of a lighter monocoque body, six-speed gearbox), although…[Read more]

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Saju Devassy 1 year, 3 months ago

        Its like the current choice between KF Airlines and Indigo. Just like KF is for Galm and beauty, so is XUV, for Reliability, Consistencey and a little nagging issues its the Tata Safari, I own a safari as old as 45 days….

      • Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
         
        Rishabh P Nair 1 year, 3 months ago

        The Safari Storme looks a little less mean and SUV like. Plus the XUV500 is just very feature rich. If space is not paramount go for the XUV500.

    Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
  • Profile picture of Piyush
     
    Help me choose between the Mahindra XUV500 or Toyota Fortuner? Price is not an issue but I want a car that is worth for future prospects as well.
    4 answers
      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Aravindhan 1 year, 3 months ago

        Budget aside, choosing between an XUV500 and a Toyota Fortuner depends on what your primary needs are. If you are going to be using the vehicle primarily in city traffic or out on the highway, with occasional rough road use, the XUV500 will perfectly suit your needs (and save you plenty of cash). However, if you want that butch image, tough,…[Read more]

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Roshun Povaiah 1 year, 3 months ago

        The Fortuner is likely to hold its resale value better in the long term. Although it doesn’t have half as many features as the XUV, when it comes to reliability and peace of mind, the Fortuner scores much better. WHile the XUV500 is feature rich, the longevity of these features (especially the electronics) needs to be seen.

      • Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
         
        Rishabh P Nair 1 year, 3 months ago

        Even if price is nute an issue you need to decide what you really want from your SUV. The Fortuner is bigger and feels several times more classy and sophisticated. The XUV500 with all its features is tempting but the Fortuner will have a higher coat of ownership. At the end of the day you are choosing between a Manhidra and a Toyota so you need to…[Read more]

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Devdath Narayan 1 year, 3 months ago

        By future prospects if you mean long term ownership for say, the next 10 years or more, than it is the Fortuner that makes sense, else it is the XUV.

    Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
  • Profile picture of Akshay Vinayak
     
    Not a question tho ... my XUV is coming on this Gudi Padwa. Thanks to Mr. Roshan Poviah Mr. Babychen Mathew and other experts for valuable information about the car :) Thanks a ton.
    2 answers
      • Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
         
        Rishabh P Nair 1 year, 3 months ago

        Congratulations Akshay, hope you enjoy driving around town in your brand new XUV :)

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Roshun Povaiah 1 year, 3 months ago

        Wow. Great news Akshay. Looking forward to a nice owner review from you :-D

    Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
  • Profile picture of %s
     
    Which one is the best among Skoda Fabia Elegance TDi, Hyundai i20 Asta CRDi and Suzuki Swift ZDi? And when is Hyundai gonna launch the new fluidic i20?
    3 answers
      • Profile picture of Ashwani
         
        Ashwani 1 year, 5 months ago

        If you want a complete package.. go for I20, if just for brand – Fabia but be ready for a high maintenance… and if don’t want to experiment,,, go for new Swift :D if want to look at other options,,, Figo for economy and consider Polo for looks and class….

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Babychen Mathew 1 year, 5 months ago

        Swift for super reliability. But long wait for the car. Else, i20, reliability and overall practicality and style. Fabia a bit cheaper… but not very popular, so there must be some reason for that :)

      • Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
         
        Rishabh P Nair 1 year, 5 months ago

        The Swift is a great package but depending on your dealer and location it could take a long time before you get the car. The i20 is a good option and will give you some peace of mind as well. The Fabia is a solid car and its interiors feel upmarket and well crafted however people usually have complains about Skoda’s service network and the cost of…[Read more]

    Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
  • Profile picture of Ashwin Nair
     
    Please tell me which is the better vehicle of the two, the Tata Safari VX 4X4 or the Tata Aria 4X4?
    6 answers
      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Babychen Mathew 1 year, 5 months ago

        Ahhhhh… Aria it is. Definitely. More space, good ground clearance. It is in many ways an SUV that looks like an MPV :) Problem is that very few people are buying it, and you will have to keep explaining to people why you bought it!

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        journeyman 1 year, 5 months ago

        Also consider buying the new safari Storme,it is a cross between Ol’ Safari and Aria i.e., Storme comes with Safari name with Aria’s chassis(monocoque i think)which means a class apart from Safari and below Aria.

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Aravindhan 1 year, 5 months ago

        Its better to wait for the test drive reports of the new Safari (Safari Storme) and then come to a conclusion!

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Roshun Povaiah 1 year, 5 months ago

        Aria does not have a monococque body. It is a body-on-frame vehicle only. Same with the Safari Storme. The Safari VX4x4 has a part-time switchable 4×4 system with a low-ratio gearbox that’s good for extreme off-road duties. The Aria 4×4 on the other hand is only an All-wheel drive when the situation demands, and can handle only mild off-roading.…[Read more]

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Ankit Tripathi 1 year, 5 months ago

        I would just say one word for ARIA , another BIG time flop show by TATA’s.

      • Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
         
        Rishabh P Nair 1 year, 3 months ago

        If ur buying a 4×4 then the Safari makes more sense but if ur not going to be off roading that much the Aria is a better bet. Question is do u want to spend the extra money? There are plenty of better choices out there!

    Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
  • Profile picture of golu.hbk
     
    Prices of Mini Cooper Variants(Ex-Showroom, Delhi/Mumbai) 1398cc Cooper Hatch Rs. 16,00,000 1598cc Cooper S Rs. 18,00,000 Cooper Coupe Rs. 20,00,000 Cooper Convertible Rs. 21,00,000 Cooper Roadster Rs. 22,00,000 1600cc Cooper Countryman Rs. 24,00,000
    2 answers

    Mini Cooper

    ANSWER THIS
    Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
  • Profile picture of Farhan Kash
     
    Hi I have a budget of around Rs.7 lakh and I want to buy a petrol sedan as I dont cross 1500km/month. Should I go for the Hyundai Verna 1.4 or the Honda City 1.5 base variant? Is there any other car that I should give a thought to?
    13 answers
      • Profile picture of Yogesh
         
        Yogesh 1 year, 5 months ago

        buddy, close ur eyes &go with Honda City. Best Petrol Sedan of its class. Or else also look out for Fiat Linea. Looks cool, ride &handling is gr8 &right nw gr8 offers too goin on.

      • Profile picture of Raviraj Samant
         
        Raviraj Samant 1 year, 5 months ago

        Honda City CE :D in Tafeta White and get Black Konig Theory Alloys m/ Done :P :)

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        journeyman 1 year, 5 months ago

        Honda city Corporate edition is much better than fluidic verna,City feels better in terms of comfort on all 5 seats,better refined petrol engine but only lacks features

      • Profile picture of Rahul Chellani
         
        Rahul Chellani 1 year, 5 months ago

        I agree with all the comments above, with the price cuts now city is the best, also if u wanna keep it for long time,see if u can buy it within this year as dealers are giving discounts this time of the year as ppl dnt prefer buying cars at end of year,cos waiting a month gives the tag of a next year model, hence bettr resale value in future.

      • Profile picture of Farhan Kash
         
        Farhan Kash 1 year, 5 months ago

        Thanks for the advices guys.. I think i will go for honda city then.

      • Profile picture of Farhan Kash
         
        Farhan Kash 1 year, 5 months ago

        What about the black colour? at least the ORVMs will match the colour body :P

      • Profile picture of Rahul Chellani
         
        Rahul Chellani 1 year, 5 months ago

        @ Farhan: Black looks good on City, so does white, and that maroonish colour, dnt know its exact name, the red wine kinda colour.. And I guess it wont make much diffrence when you buy, cos I just saw ad in todays paper that Skoda is giving 70,00 off on Laura till 31st dec. Considering a similar or even 50k discount on City, I guess that much would…[Read more]

      • Profile picture of Farhan Kash
         
        Farhan Kash 1 year, 5 months ago

        ‎@rahul i guess the colour name is Red pearl.. yes but i don’t think city will be having any discount offer for the new year as its facelift has been recently launched..

      • Profile picture of Farhan Kash
         
        Farhan Kash 1 year, 5 months ago

        As city CE doesn’t have body coloured ORVMs and door handles, so i guess black will suit the CE city.

      • Profile picture of Rahul Chellani
         
        Rahul Chellani 1 year, 5 months ago

        @ Farhan: You are right, honda may not be willing to give another discount when the prices have just been cut.. And yes, black looks best on City, it makes it look a segment higher in my opinion, especially in night. :)

      • Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
         
        Rishabh P Nair 1 year, 5 months ago

        If its features that you are looking for the Verna is packed to the tee but the Honda City still scores in terms of ride and handling. You may also consider the Fiat Linea, Volkswagen Vento, Skoda Rapid etc. However since you are looking for a petrol sedan the you can’t really go wrong with any of these cars!

    Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
  • Profile picture of Tushar_Bhople
     
    Honda CRV or Mitusbishi Ooutlander?
    4 answers
      • Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
         
        Rishabh P Nair 1 year, 5 months ago

        I’d say the Outlander, because: Rockford Fosgate Sound System, Twin opening tail Gate, Deadly looking projector headlamps, Selectable All wheel drive, more powerful, Cheaper !!

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        Roshun Povaiah 1 year, 5 months ago

        The Mitsubishi Outlander is a great vehicle, but the service network is quite poor. Otherwise in all aspects its a better deal than the CR-V.

    Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
  • Profile picture of Shah Aamir
     
    Which one should I buy; Mahindra XUV500 or Toyota Innova? Another question is why was Hero Honda Hunk a flop bike?
    15 answers
      • Profile picture of Shah Aamir
         
        Shah Aamir 1 year, 8 months ago

        Ha ha ha… Dude u get hill ascend, hill descend, cruise control, climate control 4 x 4, voice command…. what else do u expect in a 12 lakh car??

      • Profile picture of Varun Kannan
         
        Varun Kannan 1 year, 8 months ago

        when ur on a hill, u activate sum button and d car stops slidng down.

      • Profile picture of Shah Aamir
         
        Shah Aamir 1 year, 8 months ago

        Go and tell him to go and design a car for himself… Scorpio = Matchbox, Innova = Egg shaped, XUV 500 = CHEAP QUALITY INTERIORS… Dws Auto has got 80.000 likes and when they are saying it is good, who is he to comment???

      • Profile picture of Shah Aamir
         
        Shah Aamir 1 year, 8 months ago

        Hill ascend control = When u are going up a hill and your car goes off, any normal car will start rolling down… but XUV 500 gives u time to maintain the pickup and it doesnt start coming backwards…

      • Profile picture of Shah Aamir
         
        Shah Aamir 1 year, 8 months ago

        Hill descend control = If you are coming down a slope, like the one in Raheja Vihar, you can leave the car in neutral and the car wont go about 30 km/ph

      • Profile picture of CarToq Editor
         
        CarToq Editor 1 year, 8 months ago

        ?Shah Aamir we are doing a video of the xuv500, and you can see hill descent control in it probably. Between the two vehicles, it is a tough decision. Both are comfortable etc, but Innova has slightly more space after the third row at the back for some luggage. XUV doesnt have space after 3rd row. Image – Innova has become boring, but XUV is new…[Read more]

      • Profile picture of Shah Aamir
         
        Shah Aamir 1 year, 8 months ago

        Definitely, Toyota is known for its vehicle’s quality….

      • Profile picture of %s
         
        journeyman 1 year, 8 months ago

        I would choose XUV over Innova because even if you accidentally happen to break any plastic part in the Innova it will cost you a bomb for being a’Q’ Class product,But Mahindra’s you can easily get it fixed at low cost and the same applies also for Tata

      • Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
         
        Rishabh P Nair 1 year, 5 months ago

        The Innova has space for luggage even if the third row of seats is being used. The XUV500 can hardly hold a duffle bag or two with the third row of seats up. Off course the XUV is loaded with features like, static bending lights, daytime running lamps, lounge lighting, the list just goes on and on. The Innova cannot compete with the XUV when it…[Read more]

    Profile picture of Rishabh P Nair
Close

Join India's friendliest car community

275,000 Sign Up
Go To Top

Register and start asking Questions

Log into Cartoq.com

Log into Cartoq.com