What are some of the best budget cars, or value for money cars in India? Let’s look at the compact sedans Honda Amaze and Tata Tigor to see what attracts budget-conscious buyers to them.
In this article, we will discuss
- What a budget-conscious buyer looks for in a car
- Honda Amaze vs Tata Tigor – a comprehensive analysis of their variants, features, affordability, and fuel efficiency
- How to pick the right car for you
So, can these cars be called the best budget compact sedans? Are they affordable car options, or the most affordable cars in the compact sedan segment in India? Let’s find out.
What a Budget-conscious buyer looks for in a car
A budget-conscious buyer should look for these in a car:
- Affordability – a car should be affordable, and have low maintenance costs
- Fuel efficiency – The car shouldn’t guzzle fuel
- Safety features – Essential safety features are a must in a car
- Brand perception – Is the brand of the car known for its wide service network, after sales service, etc.
- Resale value – The car should fetch good resale rates
A budget-conscious buyer primarily seeks value for money, which translates to optimum performance, fuel efficiency, and essential safety features at an affordable price. Longevity, low maintenance costs, and decent resale value also influence their decision.
They may compromise on luxury add-ons but wouldn’t risk essentials like airbags and ABS. Additionally, a car’s mileage can be a game-changer, given the ever-rising fuel prices.
Why Honda Amaze and Tata Tigor are Popular
The Honda Amaze and Tata Tigor have made significant marks in the compact sedan segment, especially among budget-conscious buyers. Both these cars deliver promising fuel efficiency, which is a top priority for this demographic.
The Honda Amaze is renowned for its refined engine, spacious interiors, and the reliability associated with the Honda badge.
On the other hand, Tata Tigor has been lauded for its value-for-money proposition, offering commendable features at a competitive price point. Tata’s recent emphasis on safety and improved build quality adds trust.
Moreover, both cars offer crucial safety features like ABS and airbags even in their base variants, emphasizing the manufacturers’ commitment to value and safety.
The efficient after-sales service of Honda and the growing trust in Tata’s recent lineup further bolster their appeal.
Honda Amaze and Tata Tigor Variants Shortlist in Rs 7-10 Lakh Range
For Honda Amaze, we have:
|Variant||Price (INR) as on 1 September 2023|
For Tata Tigor, we have:
|Variant||Price (INR) as on 1 September 2023|
Honda Amaze S
At ₹767,000, it offers vital safety features like ABS and 2 airbags, combined with a decent mileage of 18.6 kmpl. This variant provides a balance of essential features at an affordable rate. If you’re a family-focused buyer, you can read our comparison of the Amaze with Maruti Ciaz.
Honda Amaze S CVT
Priced at ₹857,000, it provides the comfort of a CVT transmission along with the same features as the ‘S’ variant but with a slight compromise on mileage.
Honda Amaze VX
This variant, priced at ₹878,000, offers an LCD touchscreen and alloy wheels, providing a touch of luxury alongside essentials. We have also compared the Amaze with Maruti Suzuki Dzire for budget-conscious buyers.
Tata Tigor XZ
With a tag of ₹715,000, is the cheapest variant on our list. It promises a slightly better mileage of 19.28 kmpl than the Amaze S, coupled with key safety and convenience attributes. If you’re a safety-conscious buyer, you can read our guide to the best Tigor variants for you.
Tata Tigor XMA AMT
Priced at ₹730,000, this offers the ease of an AMT transmission, essential for city driving, while retaining primary features.
Tata Tigor XZ Plus
At ₹780,000, it offers features like an LCD touchscreen and alloy wheels, just like the Amaze VX, but at a lower price point.
Our Pick for the Best variant among Honda Amaze and Tata Tigor for Budget-conscious buyers
Considering the balance of price, safety, fuel efficiency, and necessary conveniences, the Tata Tigor XZ emerges as the top pick. At ₹715,000, it not only is more affordable than its Amaze counterparts but also offers a competitive mileage of 19.28 kmpl.
Despite its lower price tag, it doesn’t compromise on safety, offering 2 airbags and ABS. The presence of power steering, power windows, and rear parking sensors emphasize driver comfort and convenience.
The trust in Tata’s improved build quality and the value-for-money aspect of this variant makes it an attractive choice that fits your wallet.
The Top 3 choices
- Tata Tigor XZ
- Honda Amaze S
- Tata Tigor XMA AMT
|Attributes||Tata Tigor XZ||Honda Amaze S||Tata Tigor XMA AMT|
|City Mileage (kmpl)||19.28||18.6||19.6|
|Engine – Fuel type||Petrol||Petrol||Petrol|
|Power Windows – Front||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Power Windows – Back||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Overall Mileage (kmpl)||19.28||18.6||19.6|
How to Pick the Right Car for You
- The Tata Tigor XZ takes the lead due to its comprehensive features at an affordable price point.
- Honda Amaze S is a close second, bringing Honda’s reliability and almost similar features but at a slightly higher price.
- Tata Tigor XMA AMT, while slightly more expensive than the XZ, offers the comfort of automated manual transmission, making city commutes more comfortable.
All three variants fit within your budget, providing a balance of safety, fuel efficiency, and essential conveniences.
If you’re interested in reading more such face-to-face comparisons of popular car variants, head over to our Buying Advice section.